Printing the explicit photo of a woman stabbed by her husband was the right thing to do. Sadly, it didn’t work.


The woman is topless, lying face down on a hospital bed. Out of her back, a little above her waist, protrudes the wooden handle of a large knife. Only a small part of the blade is visible; the rest is buried deep into her abdomen. There is remarkably little blood, but the photograph is no less horrifying. It’s a harrowing sight.

Click to enlarge

It appeared on the front page of last Friday’s Habertürk, one of Turkey’s most popular newspapers, intended to raise awareness of domestic violence in the family. The woman in the photograph, who later died, was beaten regularly by her husband.

A carefully-chosen, striking photograph in a mass-circulation newspaper can sometimes do in a day what a well-organised pressure group can’t in a year: it can whip up public anger, steal the agenda and force someone somewhere to start changing a law.

This photograph, which you can see for yourself by clicking the link at the bottom of this post, is certainly shocking enough to do that. But it didn’t work: a week has gone by since that edition of Haberturk went to press, and yet more Turks appear angry at at the editor for printing the photograph than at the husband for wielding the knife.

Women’s rights groups gathered outside Habertürk‘s offices to protest on Sunday demanding a withdrawal and apology from Fatih Altaylı, the paper’s editor. Think of the children who saw it in all its lurid detail, they said. Mediz, a media monitor for women’s rights, called the photograph “the ultimate stage in pornography” (referencing Habertürk‘s headline, “the ultimate stage in violence towards women”) and said the newspaper had become a perpetrator of the violence by publishing it. Even Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, the prime minister, disagreed with the decision.

But Mr Altaylı has been bullish. “I would have printed this even if it was a photograph of my own mother. In fact, I would have enlarged it,” he wrote in an editorial on Saturday. “I printed it so that my 11-year-old daughter could see, at her young age, the violence that a male-dominated society inflicts on women. I printed it so she could learn to reproach those who remain silent.” An article in the Wall Street Journal has him go further:

Mr. Altayli described women’s-rights organizations that protested outside the newspaper’s offices Sunday as “idiots” who knew nothing about “real life” and what it took to make the government act. “I knew people would criticize me, that they would say I was cruel, but someone had to do it,” he said in an interview on Tuesday. “Another six women have been killed since her.”

The figures given by the Wall Street Journal are chilling enough: 42 percent of Turkish women say they have suffered physical or sexual abuse from their partner. Nearly half of those victims didn’t tell a soul what happened; an astonishing 92 percent didn’t seek what little help the authorities can give. Şefika Etik, the victim in the Habertürk photograph, was one of the rare few who actually took refuge at a safe house before her husband came calling a reconciliation. He had a bunch of flowers, Habertürk reports, and was extremely sorry. Within an hour of her return home, the knives came out.

This photograph was printed to horrify and provoke, and it succeeded on both counts. The anger at Mr Altaylı has been palpable. Journalists from Habertürk and rival papers alike have written to criticise the decision to publish. One commentator writing in Bugün, a centre-right daily, questioned Mr Altaylı’s apparent conversion to feminism by trawling through some of his earlier journalism, which includes some unflattering stories about a long-distance runner who had an affair with her personal trainer.

But however sinister Mr Altaylı’s motives may or may not be, and even if he only wants to sell more newspapers, he has brought prominence to a shameful truth about the place of women in Turkish society. In too many marriages Turkish women are “bequeathed” into the moral ownership of their husbands. Mr Erdoğan’s government has shied away from daycare projects to help mothers back into work, abolished a cabinet portfolio for women’s rights in favour a Ministry for Families, and frequently calls for newlyweds to aim for “at least” three children. These policies reflect a deeply conservative streak in Turkish society that promotes the family unit over the individual; Mr Altaylı’s critics, many of them liberal-minded, are guilty of pretending that strain doesn’t exist.

Last modified: Sunday 15 February 2015

6 Responses to :
Printing the explicit photo of a woman stabbed by her husband was the right thing to do. Sadly, it didn’t work.

  1. Jhen says:

    Every Breath
    nothing is ever as it seems
    make-up covers the bruises but nothing erases the pain
    of knowing the one you love so much could near kill you
    blindfold through a mine field every time you make a sound
    and there comes a time when you know that no ones coming to your rescue
    there comes a time where there’s no one else around
    because the cross you’re carrying is too heavy for anyone else to bear
    and each day a little more of you dies deep inside
    the spark in your eyes goes out
    and you’ve nowhere left to hide
    nothing comes out when you try to shout
    nothing comes out when you try to shout
    you know you took a wrong turn somewhere way back there
    and you don’t know how you let him go this far
    you don’t know how you let him go this far
    waiting so long for him to care
    you forgot love isn’t supposed to feel like a battle field
    where all your hopes and dreams are stripped away
    but all those cease to matter when you’re just fighting for that next breath
    they reach to hug you and your arms go up like a shield
    cause you never know when that next blow is coming your way
    till one day you take that last shred of sanity
    and weave your way back to yourself somehow
    through faith and grace you bend the laws of time and find yourself in a different reality
    where your own life means more to you then you ever imagined
    and peace is the only home you know
    now the world begins to mirror this back to you
    and every breath you take is true
    every breath you take is for you

    © 2011 Jhenya Lovering

    I hope you don’t mind me sharing this here. Thank you for the story and the picture as more awareness is desperately needed.

  2. Al says:

    Printing something like that on the front page of a daily publication is detestable. I wonder why the people doing >offset printing for the paper didn’t stop the presses right away.

  3. Eloise says:

    At least it isn’t large format printing for the whole world to see. Let’s just choose to look on the bright side.

  4. It is surprising that photo was allowed to be published. People shouldn’t be mad at the photo editor but to the husband who murdered her wife. I am not mad at the editor but he should have draw a cartoon portraying the gruesome picture of the dead woman.

Comments are closed.